The quality of cutting picks can be judged from the following aspects:
1. Visual Inspection
Tooth Body
Observe whether the surface of the tooth body is smooth and whether there are obvious sand holes, air holes, or casting defects. A high-quality cutting pick tooth body should undergo fine processing, with a flat and smooth surface, which can reduce stress concentration during operation. For example, if there are sand holes on the surface of the tooth body, cracks may first appear in these areas during the cutting process, leading to damage to the cutting pick.
Check whether the size of the tooth body meets the standards. Cutting picks with high dimensional accuracy can be better installed on the drum of a shearer or roadheader, ensuring stability during the cutting process. Tools such as calipers can be used to measure key dimensions of the tooth body, such as length and diameter, to check if they are within the specified tolerance range.

Cemented Carbide Tip
Check the welding quality of the cemented carbide tip. For a wear-resistant cutting pick, the welding joint between the cemented carbide tip and the tooth body should be full and continuous, without defects such as cold welding, missing welding, or inclusions. A preliminary judgment can be made by observing the appearance of the welding joint to see if there are obvious gaps or uneven welding spots. For example, a cutting pick with cold welding may have the cemented carbide tip easily fall off during operation, which is likely to reduce the service life of the cutting pick.
Observe the shape and size of the cemented carbide tip. The shape of the cemented carbide tip should be regular, with a sharp cutting edge and no chipping. The size should also meet the design requirements, as it directly affects the cutting performance of the cutting pick. For example, a cutting pick with a blunt cutting edge will increase cutting resistance and reduce work efficiency when cutting coal or rock.
Coating (if any)
For cutting picks with a coating, check whether the coating is uniform and intact. The main function of the coating is to improve the wear resistance and corrosion resistance of the cutting pick. If the coating is uneven, with exposed substrate or peeling, the cutting pick is prone to corrosion and wear in harsh working environments. Tools such as microscopes can be used to observe the microstructure of the coating and check its quality.
2. Material Quality
Tooth Body Material
Understand the material composition of the tooth body. Generally speaking, the wear-resistant tooth body material is alloy steel, which has high strength and toughness. Relevant information about the tooth body material can be obtained by checking the product manual or consulting the manufacturer. For example, 42CrMo alloy steel is a material commonly used for the tooth body of cutting picks, and its performance indicators such as yield strength and tensile strength can meet the requirements of cutting picks in high-load working environments.
Check whether the heat treatment process of the material is reasonable. Appropriate heat treatment can improve the hardness and wear resistance of the tooth body. The heat treatment quality of the tooth body can be tested through hardness testing. The Rockwell hardness (HRC) testing method is generally used. The hardness of a high-quality cutting pick tooth body is usually between HRC40 – 50. This hardness range enables the tooth body to have sufficient strength to withstand cutting forces while maintaining a certain toughness to prevent the tooth body from breaking.

Cemented Carbide Material
The quality of the cemented carbide tip is crucial. Common cemented carbide materials include tungsten-cobalt (YG) and tungsten-titanium-cobalt (YT) types. YG cemented carbide has good toughness and is suitable for cutting coal and rock with certain toughness; YT cemented carbide has higher hardness and is suitable for cutting harder rocks. The composition and quality of cemented carbide can be checked by referring to the quality report provided by the manufacturer to see if the contents of main elements such as tungsten, cobalt, and titanium meet the standards.
The hardness and density of cemented carbide are also important indicators to measure its quality. Generally speaking, the higher the hardness of the cemented carbide, the better its wear resistance. Hardness testing equipment (such as a Vickers hardness tester) can be used to detect the hardness of the cemented carbide tip. At the same time, density can also reflect the quality of the cemented carbide. A density that does not meet the standard may indicate that there are defects such as pores inside the material, affecting its performance.
3. Performance Testing
Wear Resistance Test
Carry out a wear resistance test on the cutting pick under conditions simulating the actual working environment. The cutting pick can be installed on test equipment and made to rub against simulated coal and rock materials under a certain pressure and rotation speed. The wear resistance is evaluated by recording the wear amount of the cutting pick within a certain period of time. For example, under the same test conditions, a cutting pick with a small wear amount indicates good wear resistance and high quality.

Impact Toughness Test
Since the cutting pick is subject to large impact forces during operation, impact toughness is an important performance indicator. An impact testing machine is used to test the impact toughness of the cutting pick, observing whether the cutting pick has damage such as cracks or fractures after being subjected to a certain amount of impact energy. A high-quality cutting pick can withstand multiple impacts without damage, indicating that it has good impact toughness.