The real culprit of the several times difference in pick durability is not “good or bad”, but the systematic mismatch of raw materials, technology, selection and on-site management.

Strange phenomena often occur in mining tunnel construction: two batches of picks with the same appearance, the same tunnel, the same equipment, the same stratum, but the lifespan is several times different. The truth cannot be summed up by the words “good or bad”. Durability is the system result determined by raw materials, technology, selection, operation and maintenance.

1. Raw Material Basics: Determine the upper limit of performance

The pick is composed of a carbide head and an alloy steel tooth body.

Carbide heads pay attention to the balance of “hardness and toughness”: fine grains have high hardness and are suitable for highly abrasive hard rock, but are prone to collapse under impact; coarse grains have strong impact resistance and are suitable for semi-coal rocks and soft-hard interlayers. The misunderstanding is to blindly pursue hardness. High hardness under impact conditions will lead to brittle cracks and a sudden decrease in service life.

2. Manufacturing process: determine the lower limit of durability

After the raw materials meet the standards, heat treatment and brazing are the keys to widening the gap.

  • Heat treatment creates “tough inside and stiff outside”: If the workmanship is excellent, the surface layer is wear-resistant, the core is tough enough, and the handle can absorb impact and prevent the handle from breaking; if the temperature control is unstable, the whole body will be too brittle or too soft, and stress concentration will lead to frequent fractures.
  • Brazing is the lifeblood of preventing U-turns: manual welding is prone to weak welds, pores, and cracks when shocked; mature technology uses vacuum brazing to form a stable metallurgical bond and prevent the alloy from falling off from the source. In addition, the tooth body surfacing wear-resistant layer and tolerance control are also crucial. Excessive clearance will cause the eccentric wear rate to double.
Mailinmat vacuum equipment

3. Working condition matching: Mismatch between model and stratum is the number one killer of durability.

Different strata require different models, and choosing the wrong one will be a waste:

  • Soft coal (f≤3): Mainly due to wear, choose conventional economical wear-resistant models;
  • Semi-coal rock (f=4~7): Impact wear coexists, taking into account both wear resistance and impact resistance;
  • Hard rock high quartz (f≥8): extremely abrasive, the tooth protection and anti-collapse performance must be strengthened.

When the same tunnel has soft and hard layers, if the soft rock model is used, the consumption will increase significantly, and the selection must be “varied by rock.”

4. On-site operation and maintenance: gear base, operation, cooling – three “on-site variables” that determine durability

Even if the product is perfect, improper operation and maintenance will still shorten its life:

  • Tooth seat clearance: The wear of the tooth seat causes the pick to be unable to rotate, resulting in fixed eccentric wear. Ensuring appropriate clearance to allow smooth rotation is a low-cost means of extending life;
  • Operating habits: Forcibly pushing hard rock and impacting at full load will generate additional lateral force, which will amplify the risk of fracture and require reasonable speed control;
  • Cooling conditions: The cutting temperature can reach 600~800℃. If the spray cooling is not in place, the material will soften at high temperature and wear will be accelerated rapidly.

5. Improvement path: jump out of price comparison and reduce system costs

To break the vicious cycle of “low-price purchasing → frequent replacement → shutdown and missed work”, you should follow a 5-step method:

1. Failure traceability: count whether it is bald, cracked, turned around or broken, and identify the shortcomings;

2. Stratum first: measured f value and quartz content, reject one-size-fits-all procurement;

3. Pay attention to the process threshold: select suppliers with traceable raw materials and automatic heat treatment and brazing capabilities, not just the unit price;

4. Strengthen on-site management: regularly replace gear seats, standardize operations, and ensure spraying;

5. Comparative test in the same field: The cost of consumables per unit footage is the only criterion, not the life of a single unit.

Conclusion:

Although the pick is small, it is the core of excavation. The loss gap is a comprehensive reflection of raw materials, technology, selection and management. Only by clarifying the internal logic can we truly reduce downtime losses and total consumable costs.