When purchasing picks, “the larger the alloy head, the more wear-resistant it is” is a common misunderstanding. Many purchasing managers only judge quality based on alloy size, mistakenly believing that size determines lifespan, and eventually fall into the predicament of rising costs and low efficiency. Based on the actual experience of thousands of mines, Mailinmat dismantles the core misunderstandings and provides buyers with scientific selection ideas to achieve working condition adaptation, cost reduction and efficiency improvement.

Source of misunderstanding: Why has “big alloy head” become the first choice?
Buyers prefer large alloy heads due to intuitive demands for wear resistance and information gaps. On the one hand, as a core wear-resistant component, the size advantage of the alloy head can easily lead to the perception of “plentiful materials and long service life”, and the size is intuitive and easy to quantify, making it the first choice for purchasing reference; on the other hand, some small manufacturers deliberately exaggerate the role of size and ignore the adaptation of processes and working conditions, solidifying this misunderstanding. In fact, the durability of picks is a comprehensive result of size, material, process and working conditions, and cannot be determined by a single dimension.
Hidden dangers: four core disadvantages of large alloy heads
As the saying goes, the extremes of things must be reversed. Large alloy heads that exceed the requirements of working conditions cannot improve performance. Instead, they cause chain problems and lead to an imbalance in cost performance.
- Cutting resistance surges and efficiency and energy consumption are imbalanced
The size of the alloy head is positively related to the cutting resistance. Excessive size will increase the contact area. On medium-soft coal seams or low-power equipment below F8 level, it is easy to cause the equipment load to exceed the standard, the speed to decline, the tunneling speed to drop by 15%-25%, and the energy consumption to rise by more than 20%, forming a “high input, low output” cycle.
- The balance of hardness and toughness is broken, and the risk of fracture soars.
The core of the pick’s durability is “hard-tough balance”. The weight of the large alloy head increases and the material is brittle. In impact conditions where gangue is contained and rock formations are broken, it is susceptible to uneven force and stress concentration, and the risk of fracture is more than 40% higher than that of adapted size picks. After Mailinmat replaced cutting picks with adapted sizes for a mine in Inner Mongolia, the breakage rate dropped by 80% and the equipment availability increased significantly.
- Poor equipment adaptation, exacerbating collateral losses
The cutting head speed, gear seat size and other parameters of coal shearers and tunnel boring machines are fixed, and large alloy heads are prone to adaptation deviations, resulting in loosening and eccentric wear problems. This not only shortens the life of the pick, but also increases the wear of the cutting head and tool holder, increasing equipment maintenance costs and downtime.
- The overall cost is high and the price/performance ratio is upside down.
The unit price of large alloy-head picks is 30%-50% higher than that of adapted models, and due to low efficiency and many faults, the labor for tooth replacement and downtime losses increase simultaneously. According to actual measurements in a coal mine with an annual output of 1 million tons, the comprehensive cost per month increased by nearly 800,000 yuan after use, and the price/performance ratio is not as good as that of the adapted model.
Melinmate’s scientific selection method: choose the right one, not the big one, the best one is the adaptation.
The core of high-quality cutting picks is the three-dimensional adaptation of “working conditions-size-process”. Based on practical experience, Mailinmat summarizes three selection criteria to help buyers avoid pitfalls:
- Determine the size according to the hardness of the rock layer, accurate matching without waste
Selection according to rock layer hardness classification: For medium-soft coal seams below F8, a small diameter alloy head of 8-12mm can take into account both efficiency and cost; for medium-hard rock layers F10-F14, choose a medium size of 12-16mm and optimize the cutting angle; for hard rocks above F14, there is no need to increase the size, and “reasonable size + strengthening technology” can be used. Mailinmate’s 14mm diameter Co-based alloy cladding pick has a lifespan 2.5 times longer than that of the ordinary model of the same size, and the efficiency is 30% higher than that of the oversized model.
- Emphasis on craftsmanship and lightness on size, building a solid wear-resistant core

The wear resistance of the alloy head, material and process have a far greater impact than size. Mailinmate uses self-developed Fe-Ni-Co-AlWC super-hard composite material, combined with vacuum welding process, to increase the strength by 50% and optimize the cutting edge arc to reduce drag. In an F15 grade hard rock mine in Shanxi, the 14mm diameter pick was only slightly worn after 32 days of continuous operation, and its performance was better than the 18mm diameter ordinary pick under the same working conditions.
- Combined with device parameters to achieve global adaptation
The selection needs to match the equipment parameters. Melinmate has established a database covering more than 120 types of mainstream equipment, and customizes the alloy head size and tail structure according to the cutting head speed and gear seat specifications. For example, the design of the SANY tunnel boring machine can be optimized to reduce eccentric wear and looseness from the root cause.
Conclusion: Adaptation is king and the key to pick selection

Getting rid of the misunderstanding that “the bigger the alloy head is, the better” and returning to the essential selection of working conditions can reduce costs and increase efficiency. Melinmate focuses on working conditions and refuses to blindly stack sizes. It provides highly adaptable solutions through material and process upgrades and customized designs.
If you are confused about the size selection of the pick alloy head, you can contact the Melinmate technical team to obtain a free working condition survey and one-to-one selection plan. Use scientific decision-making to replace empirical judgment, so that the pick becomes a reliable support for efficient production.