How to choose picks? Full analysis of key factors to help you choose the right product

In coal mining and tunneling, picks can be called the “industrial teeth” of equipment, and their consumption costs directly affect the cost per ton of coal and the progress of the project. However, faced with a mixed bag of pick pick brands on the market, many purchasers often fall into misunderstandings: either they only focus on the unit price, or they blindly follow imports.

As a neutral technical guide, we do not support any brand. We only help you establish a scientific pick selection methodology from the six dimensions of working conditions, materials, geometric design, welding process, quality control system and comprehensive cost performance.

1. Depend on the working conditions: Prescribing the right medicine is the prerequisite

  • Coal mining environment: If it is used in coal mining, the hardness of the coal should be considered. For softer coal, the wear resistance requirements of the picks are relatively low, but if it is hard coal or coal seams containing gangue, the picks need to have higher hardness and wear resistance to prevent excessive wear.
  • Excavation conditions: During the tunnel excavation process, the rock picks face complex and diverse conditions. If it is excavation in soft rock, relatively ordinary picks can be used; if it is excavation in hard rock, high-strength picks specially designed for hard rock must be used, and the quality and welding process of the alloy head are higher to withstand greater impact and wear.

2. Look at the material: the “dual-core” test of cemented carbide and tooth steel

  • Alloy head material: The alloy head of the pick is a key part, and is generally made of carbide. High-quality cemented carbide contains a high proportion of hard components such as tungsten carbide, which has high hardness, high strength and good wear resistance.
  • Tooth body material: The tooth body is usually made of high-quality alloy steel. This kind of steel must have good toughness and strength and be able to withstand the impact force during coal mining or excavation.

3. Look at shape and size: geometry determines cutting efficiency

  • Shape design: Different pick shapes are suitable for different working scenarios. Pick-shaped picks are suitable for cutting coal and soft rock of various hardnesses, and their blade shape can effectively cut into coal and rock; while knife-shaped picks may have more advantages in certain hard rock cutting situations, and their cutting edge angle and shape can make the cutting force more concentrated.
  • Size Match: The pick size must match the cutting drum of the shearer or tunnel boring machine being used. If the pick size is not suitable, it may not be installed correctly or the cutting effect may be affected during the work. For example, the length, diameter and size of the mounting holes of the picks need to be selected strictly in accordance with the requirements of the equipment to ensure that the picks can be tightly and securely mounted on the cutting drum.

4. Look at the welding process: Invisible details determine “not falling off”

The welding quality between the alloy head and the tooth body is directly related to the service life of the pick. High-quality welding technology can ensure a firm connection between the alloy head and the tooth body, and the alloy head will not fall off under high impact and high wear conditions. High-quality manufacturers generally use advanced vacuum brazing technology and pass strict quality inspections, such as non-destructive testing, to ensure welding quality.

5. Look at brand reputation: data is more reliable than advertising

Brand reputation: It is recommended to give priority to manufacturers that have mine field application data and have passed ISO quality system certification. Choosing well-known brands of picks usually results in more reliable product quality and after-sales service. Brands with good reputations have relatively strict standards in product development, production technology and quality control. The reputation of a brand does not lie in the loudness of its advertisements, but in the repurchase rate of old customers.

User reviews: Checking the reviews of other users is also an important reference. You can learn about the actual use of different pick brands through industry forums, mining enterprise communication groups, or user reviews on product sales platforms, including information on service life, cutting efficiency, and whether they are easily damaged.

6. Look at the comprehensive cost performance: Calculate the full cycle cost account

When considering price, you should not just focus on the initial purchase price of the pick, but also consider its service life and performance. Higher-priced picks may be of better quality and performance, allowing for less frequent replacement, thus reducing costs over the long term. For example, a product that is slightly more expensive but has twice the service life of ordinary picks may be more worth buying from a cost-effective perspective.

Choosing the right pick not only reduces consumption costs, but also ensures construction progress. Please remember: working conditions are fundamental, material is the foundation, size is the hard constraint, welding is the soul, and costs must be calculated dynamically.

I hope this guide can help you clear up the fog and find the weapon that is truly suitable for your “battlefield”. If you still have questions about specific working conditions (such as f value, lithology, equipment model), please leave a message in the comment area, and we will further analyze it for you based on actual cases.