It is common to find cutting picks that look nearly identical but vary wildly in price when purchasing. Some low-cost products may be made from recycled alloy or blended materials, which are hard to distinguish with the naked eye alone.
To address this, MLMT has compiled 4 practical inspection tips for preliminary screening upon receipt of goods and mitigating procurement risks.
Tip 1: Visual Inspection – Initial Screening
This is the basic method for random checks after delivery. Examine the luster, texture of the carbide tip and welding details under natural daylight.

✅ Inspection Method: Check the overall gloss, surface flatness and edge workmanship.
✅ Reference Criteria: High-quality carbide tips: Generally present an even silver-grey tone with subtle and steady luster, smooth surfaces free of obvious pores, sand holes or discoloration, and neat welding seams. Inferior carbide tips: May appear dull, grey or mottled, with rough surfaces, tiny pores or scratches, burrs on edges and shoddy welding joints.
Tip: Products with uneven color and rough surfaces should be treated with caution, as they may be made of recycled or substandard materials.
Tip 2: Magnet Test – Detect Adulteration
This test works well for high-quality counterfeits that resemble genuine products in appearance.

✅ Operation Steps: Hold a regular magnet close to the carbide tip (avoid the carbon steel pick body below) and check if attraction occurs.
✅ Reference Criteria: High-quality carbide tips: Normally non-ferromagnetic, with no magnetic attraction when a magnet approaches. It is normal for the carbon steel pick body to be magnetic. Inferior carbide tips: Noticeably attracted by magnets, indicating possible iron-based impurities or ordinary steel inside instead of pure tungsten steel, which may fail to meet hardness and wear resistance requirements.
Tip: This method is efficient for identifying adulterated alloy. Any carbide tip with obvious magnetic attraction requires further verification.
Tip 3: Heat Test – Observe Material Response
When visual inspection raises doubts, localized high-temperature heating can help judge the purity and thermal stability of the alloy.

✅ Operation Steps: Use a spray gun or high-temperature flame to briefly heat a small area of the carbide tip, and observe color changes, cooling performance and surface condition after heating.
✅ Reference Criteria: High-quality carbide tips: Feature good high-temperature resistance. No abnormal discoloration or surface peeling usually occurs after localized heating, and the structure remains intact after cooling. Inferior carbide tips: Containing impurities or low-grade materials, they tend to suffer severe blackening, heavy oxidation or even microcracks after heating, showing poor thermal stability.
Industry Note: Some low-cost cutting picks are finely polished on the surface yet have subpar heat resistance, making the heat test a helpful auxiliary verification method.
Tip 4: Angle Grinder Test – Supplementary Verification
Use this method for confirmation if the above three tests yield inconclusive results by checking sparks and wear after grinding.

✅ Operation Steps: Gently grind the carbide tip surface for 10–20 seconds with an angle grinder and observe sparks and wear marks. Always wear safety goggles and dust masks, operate in a ventilated area, and prioritize safety.
✅ Reference Criteria: High-quality carbide tips: High hardness and wear resistance produce little to almost no sparks during grinding with considerable resistance. The ground surface stays smooth without obvious pits or scratches. Inferior carbide tips: Soft and impurity-rich materials generate abundant, splashing sparks and develop prominent scratches or pits with rapid wear.
Industry Note: Regenerated or low-grade alloy can be polished to look similar to qualified products, yet its hardness and wear resistance are far below genuine tungsten steel. The grinding test serves as a practical auxiliary check.
Closing
Keep this 4-step inspection mnemonic handy:
1️⃣ Even silver-grey luster; dull and rough picks may be defective
2️⃣ Carbide should be non-magnetic; magnetic picks imply adulteration
3️⃣ Stable under heat; heavy oxidation indicates poor material quality
4️⃣ Minimal sparks and high wear resistance; heavy sparks signal caution

A cutting pick directly impacts construction efficiency, consumable costs and equipment service life. Genuine tungsten steel with high hardness, impact resistance and wear resistance is critical for engineering cost reduction and efficiency improvement.
The identification methods above are general industry experience for procurement inspection only. Actual performance shall be subject to professional testing.
Follow MLMT, a manufacturer of original cutting picks. All our picks adopt high-purity virgin tungsten carbide tips with no recycled or blended materials, suitable for coal mining, tunneling, excavation, rotary drilling and crushing applications. Feel free to message us for model selection or inspection consultation.