During tunnel construction, many teams fall into a selection misunderstanding: the higher the hardness of the pick, the more durable it will be. However, in the working conditions of tunnels with all soil and sand and weak surrounding rock, this logic does not hold true at all. Front-line construction experience proves that for excavation in soft rock, soil and sand strata, the picks do not need extremely high hardness. Comprehensive toughness is the core of cost reduction and efficiency improvement. Blindly pursuing high hardness will only cause problems such as hard and brittle picks, easy cracking and broken handles, and doubling of consumable loss.

01 Why are high hardness cutting picks not suitable for soft rock tunnels?
High-hardness cutting picks are a necessity for hard rock formations. They rely on high hardness to resist strong wear and high cutting resistance. However, soft surrounding rocks such as full-sand, silty clay, and pebbles have loose soil, poor cementability, and no hard rocks. The overall abrasiveness is extremely low. Qualified conventional picks will basically not be worn, and the wear-resistant advantages of high hardness are of no use.
On the other hand, the hidden risks in working conditions will infinitely amplify the shortcomings of high-hardness picks. The soil quality of the soft rock formation is uneven, often mixed with hard soil and scattered pebbles. During excavation, the cutterhead continuously vibrates and the force fluctuates greatly. The tunnel is superimposed with water seepage and water inrush. The picks are subjected to alternating impact loads for a long time. The material characteristics are inherently higher in hardness, worse in toughness, and more brittle. High-hardness picks sacrifice impact resistance and fatigue resistance for wear resistance. In the end, most of them are scrapped due to alloy chipping and tooth fracture. This is also the core reason for the high loss of picks in soft rock tunnels.

02 The truth behind the failure of soft rock picks: Insufficient toughness is far greater than insufficient hardness
The scrapping of picks in hard rock tunnels is mostly due to normal wear and tear, while in soft surrounding rocks of soil, sand, and more than 90% of pick damages are structural damage caused by lack of toughness. Mainly divided into two categories: first, the cemented carbide head collapses and breaks off pieces. High-hardness alloys are brittle and cannot buffer the instantaneous impact and continuous vibration of excavation. They are easily cracked and fallen off when encountering scattered hard objects; second, the tooth body is bent and fractured. Soft rock excavation is continuous extrusion cutting, and the picks are subjected to alternating stress for a long time. The tooth body with insufficient toughness is easy to accumulate fatigue damage and eventually deform and break.
High-toughness cutting pick adapted to soft rock working conditions. By optimizing the alloy formula, adjusting the grain size, and moderately reducing the hardness, the bending resistance, impact resistance, and fatigue resistance are greatly improved. It can buffer the impact force through slight deformation, perfectly adapt to the complex working conditions of soft rock, and significantly reduce the failure rate.

03 Core principle: In soft rock excavation, toughness must precede hardness.
The hardness and toughness of cemented carbide balance each other: high-hardness fine-grained alloys are extremely wear-resistant but highly brittle, and are suitable for hard rock; moderately optimizing the ratio and reducing part of the hardness can significantly improve the structural stability of the alloy. Soft rock formations do not have high-intensity wear pressure, and only basic wear resistance can meet construction needs. High-frequency vibration and alternating impact are the biggest tests of construction, which also makes medium hardness and high toughness the optimal solution for soft rock picks.

04 Soft rock tunnel cutting pick floor selection & usage guide
1. Core selection: Abandon the obsession with ultra-high hardness and select special picks for soft rock with a flexural strength of ≥2200MPa and a balance of soft and hard. Focus on the alloy ratio and heat treatment process to ensure the toughness and stability of the tooth body.
2. Structural adaptation: Prioritize the use of a pointed cone, large intercept and long tooth structure, which has low cutting resistance, fast powder discharge, is not easy to accumulate mud and slip, and effectively reduces the pick load.
3. Construction specifications: Avoid hard tops with high speeds and strong thrusts, maintain smooth excavation at a constant speed, reduce the start and stop of the cutterhead and sudden changes in speed, reduce fatigue damage of the picks, and extend the service life.

Conclusion
When selecting tunnel consumables, adaptation is always better than parameter stacking. Hard rock fights for hardness, soft rock fights for toughness. When constructing in soft surrounding rock with all soil and sand, focusing on the toughness and stability of picks can reduce tooth chipping and broken handle failures from the root cause, reduce downtime and lost time for tooth replacement, and achieve two-way optimization of consumable costs and construction efficiency. This is also the most cost-effective construction option on the construction site.
Focus on practical practical information on tunnel excavation consumables to help reduce costs and improve efficiency on construction sites! If you need a special high-toughness cutting pick selection solution for soft rock, please leave a message to communicate.