Why Do Cutting Picks Wear Quickly Even in Soft Coal Seams? Which Key Details Are You Overlooking?

At coal mine excavation sites, many construction teams have such a confusion: it is understandable that cutting picks wear quickly in hard coal seams, but in obviously soft coal seams, the wear rate of cutting picks is not low at all, and even needs to be replaced more frequently than when working in hard coal seams. This not only pushes up the construction cost, but also seriously slows down the excavation progress due to frequent shutdowns for pick replacement. In fact, the rapid wear of cutting picks in soft coal seams is not an “unsolvable mystery”; the problem often lies in those overlooked key details.

Misconception: Soft Coal Seams = Low Wear? Don’t Be Deceived by the “Soft” Appearance

Many people take it for granted that since soft coal seams have low hardness, the cutting picks will suffer less force during cutting and thus naturally wear less. However, in actual operations, the “softness” of soft coal seams will instead give rise to unique wear problems. On one hand, soft coal seams are often accompanied by high water content and high viscosity. The crushed coal dust is easy to adhere to the pick head and matrix, forming an “abrasive layer”. When the pick rotates, these fine coal dust particles repeatedly rub the surface of the pick head like sandpaper; on the other hand, some soft coal seams contain thin layers of sandstone, shale and other hard interlayers. These “invisible obstacles” will make the cutting picks bear intermittent impact loads during the cutting process, leading to chipping of the pick head or deformation of the matrix, thereby exacerbating wear.
Construction data from a coal mine shows that when working in soft coal seams containing clay layers, the average service life of cutting picks is only 60% of that in pure soft coal seams, and the wear rate of picks that are not cleaned of coal dust in a timely manner is more than 3 times faster than those cleaned regularly. It is obvious that the wear problem in soft coal seams is far more complex than imagined.

Key Detail 1: “One-Size-Fits-All” Selection of Cutting Picks – Compatibility Is the Core

The rapid wear of cutting picks in soft coal seams is often due to improper selection as the primary issue. Many construction teams take the trouble to use the same type of cutting picks for both hard and soft coal seams, but they do not know that this “universal operation” is the root cause of accelerated wear.
In soft coal seam operations, the core requirements for cutting picks are “efficient chip removal + anti-adhesion”, rather than “high hardness and impact resistance” required for hard coal seams. If conical thick-head picks specially designed for hard coal seams are used, the contact area between the pick head and the coal seam is large, and the chip grooves are easily blocked by viscous coal dust. This not only increases cutting resistance, but also the abrasive effect of coal dust causes the pick head to fail quickly; on the contrary, cutting picks with “thin-blade arc-shaped heads + wide chip grooves” specially designed for soft coal seams can reduce the contact area with the coal body, accelerate coal dust discharge, and fundamentally reduce wear.
In addition, the angle of the pick shank also needs to be compatible. In soft coal seams, an excessively large angle of the pick shank will easily cause the pick to “penetrate” too deep into the coal seam, increasing frictional resistance; an excessively small angle will lead to “slippage” and idling wear of the pick head. Under normal circumstances, the angle of the pick shank for soft coal seams is recommended to be controlled between 15° and 20°, and specific adjustments should be made according to the viscosity and water content of the coal seam.

Key Detail 2: “Experience-Based” Construction Parameters – Precise Regulation Can Reduce Wear by Half

The “experience-based sayings” in construction, such as “the faster the cutting speed, the faster the progress” and “the greater the feed pressure, the stronger the cutting force”, will instead become “wear accelerators” for cutting picks in soft coal seam operations.
In terms of cutting speed, the coal structure of soft coal seams is loose. If the cutting speed of the roadheader exceeds 3 m/min, the crushed coal dust cannot be taken away by the chip removal device in a timely manner, forming a “buffer layer” between the cutting picks and the coal wall. The cutting picks are equivalent to “idling and grinding” in the coal dust, and the wear rate increases significantly. After a coal mine reduced the cutting speed from 4 m/min to 2.5 m/min, the service life of the cutting picks was directly extended by 40%.
The regulation of feed pressure is also crucial. If the pressure is too small, the cutting picks cannot effectively cut into the coal seam, resulting in “slippage” wear; if the pressure is too large, the cutting picks will sink into the soft coal seam, increasing the contact area between the pick shank and the coal body and exacerbating frictional wear. The reasonable feed pressure should be controlled within the range where “the cutting picks just fully cut into the coal seam without obvious sinking”, and real-time adjustments can be made by observing the chip discharge volume and machine load.

Key Detail 3: Maintenance “Only Replace When Broken” – Minor Oversights Lead to Major Wear

The maintenance of cutting picks in soft coal seams is often overlooked. Many construction teams do not replace the cutting picks until they are chipped or unable to cut, but they do not know that daily minor maintenance can significantly extend their service life.
First, “timely chip cleaning”. After each shutdown, the coal dust adhering to the surface of the cutting picks must be washed with high-pressure water guns, especially the residual coal dust in the chip grooves, to avoid the coal dust drying and hardening to form abrasive particles. If the viscosity of the coal seam is extremely high, a special anti-adhesive agent can be applied to the surface of the cutting picks to reduce coal dust adhesion. Second, “regular gap inspection”. When the gap between the cutting pick and the pick holder exceeds 0.5 mm, the cutting pick will shake during operation, leading to uneven wear. At this time, the pick holder should be replaced in a timely manner or adjustment gaskets should be added.
In addition, “batch replacement” is also important. The wear degree of the cutting picks on the same cutting head varies. If only the excessively worn cutting picks are replaced, the new cutting picks will wear quickly due to uneven force. The correct approach is that when the wear amount of some cutting picks reaches 1/3 of the diameter of the pick head, replace the cutting picks at the symmetrical positions of the cutting head in batches to ensure force balance.

Conclusion: For Cutting Pick Wear in Soft Coal Seams, Prevention Is the Key

The rapid wear of cutting picks in soft coal seams is not “inevitable”, but is caused by the combined effect of detailed omissions in multiple links such as selection, parameters, and maintenance. Breaking out of the cognitive misconception that “wear is light in soft coal seams”, accurately selecting models according to coal seam characteristics, adjusting construction parameters in combination with working conditions, and doing a good job in daily maintenance can make cutting picks efficient and durable in soft coal seam operations, and fundamentally reduce construction costs. Next time you encounter the problem of cutting pick wear in soft coal seams, you may wish to investigate one by one from these details, and you may find the key to solving the problem.